‍

Annuity vs. pension: Which retirement option is right for you?

Annuity vs. pension? It’s a common question, but it rarely has a simple either-or response. Both can provide guaranteed retirement income, and many people use them together to save more for their futures. 

{{key-takeaways}}

‍

These two common strategies can even grow alongside other investments. This type of strategy gives you several sources of income so you have a stable income floor in retirement.

Read on to learn how annuities and pensions work. We’ll show you how they differ and how combining them in a broader retirement strategy can help you build steady income. You’ll also see where retirement plan annuities fit into this mix and how they can support long-term planning.

What is an annuity?

An annuity is a financial product you can purchase from an insurance company. Many are designed for long-term saving, and they grow as you contribute funds and earn interest. In retirement, the annuity converts your balance into regular payments that support your income needs.

Annuities aren’t an employer benefit, like a pension. You fund them yourself through ongoing contributions or a lump sum. However, you can take funds that you’ve saved in a pension or other investments to buy an annuity, which provides predictable payments.

What is a pension?

A pension is an employer-sponsored retirement plan that provides income after you retire. Your employer manages the plan and promises a specific benefit, often based on your salary and years of service. Many plans require employer contributions, and some also require employee contributions.

Pensions aren’t the same as defined contribution (DC) plans like 401(k)s. In DC plans, you invest your own money and carry the market risk. DC plans also often have matching programs, where your employer contributes the same amounts you do. With pensions, the employer makes the contributions — requiring little, if any, contribution from you.

While your employer manages your pension, you choose how you receive payments in retirement. You can select a pension-provided lifetime annuity, which offers regular payments for the rest of your life. You can also choose a lump-sum payment, but the full amount is taxed as ordinary income in the year you receive it. This can create a large income tax bill.

A lump sum also carries longevity risks because you could spend it faster than expected. A pension life annuity avoids this issue. Payments continue for life, and some options extend protection to a spouse.

Annuity vs. pension plan: 5 key differences

Many people ask if an annuity is a pension. The confusion often stems from the fact that a pension plan may offer an annuitization option that pays out in steady installments. Those payments are a pension-provided annuity, but the pension plan itself is not an annuity contract. 

When considering whether to use a pension versus an annuity, pay attention to the following differences to help compare features and trade-offs.

Source of funding

Pensions are typically funded by the employer. Some plans require you to set aside a portion of your paycheck for the pension. Annuities, on the other hand, are self-funded — whether through regular deposits or a lump sum. You decide when to buy an annuity and how much to invest.

Risk and reward

Pensions are a low-risk retirement option because they guarantee income for life and are backed by the employer and supported by federal insurance programs. But if the employer’s financial health takes a downturn, your pension savings can too. 

Some self-funded annuities are also low-risk. Fixed annuities provide stable income with predictable rates. However, variable annuities present some risk, as their returns are market-dependent. While your funds can grow uncapped, you can also take a loss in a bad economy.

Another key risk-and-reward consideration is longevity. With pensions and fixed lifetime annuities, payments are guaranteed even if you live longer than expected. But variable annuities and other market-dependent retirement funds don’t offer that same protection. You could outlive your savings. 

Tax considerations

Pension payments are taxed as regular income. But taxation varies on annuities. If you have a qualified annuity, which is funded with pre-tax dollars, the IRS taxes the entire withdrawal amount. A non-qualified annuity is funded with post-tax dollars, so the IRS only taxes interest.

Fees and costs

Pensions don’t charge direct fees to retirees. But annuities include costs to help cover administration and insurance guarantees. Some fees are built into the contract. Others, like optional riders, are more visible and can add value if you want extra protection.

Investment control

You have no control over how your pension funds are invested, as they’re managed by your employer. But annuities give you more flexibility. You can choose an investment strategy that aligns with your risk tolerance level. 

Control is often the trade-off for stability. Pensions and fixed annuities guarantee income but limit investment flexibility. Variable annuities give you more control over how your money is invested, but your returns are not guaranteed.

Pension lump sum vs. annuity: How to decide

A pension isn’t the same as an annuity, but your pension may offer an annuity payout option. This “pension plan annuity” breaks your benefit into steady payments for life. You can also choose to take a lump sum. 

Scenarios where a lump sum may make sense

If you have a medical condition that lessens your life expectancy, taking a lump sum can help. You’ll be able to enjoy your savings during retirement without outliving them. A lump sum can also be smart if you’re a savvy investor and don’t mind market risk. Finally, lump sums can help if you need money to cover a major expense, like a debt or down payment on a home.

Scenarios where periodic payments may be preferable

Periodic payments provide stability. They're smart if you value or need guaranteed lifetime income — especially if you have a long life expectancy. The predictable payments also allow you to budget confidently. 

Can you combine an annuity and a pension?

Many people need more income in retirement than their pension alone can provide. A diverse retirement strategy can help build a more stable income floor, especially when you add an annuity for extra protection. Many retirees also include other investments in their portfolio, like CDs or bonds, to strengthen long-term security.

How to use annuities after you’ve made a pension decision

When considering an annuity, pension plans can influence the choices you make. 

If you take a lump sum, you can roll your pension into an IRA to keep the balance tax-deferred. Once the money is in the IRA, you can use it to buy an annuity without triggering income tax. An immediate annuity starts paying out regular deposits right away, giving you income to live on. 

Another option is to buy an annuity long before you retire. This strategy builds future income and reduces pressure on your pension plan and other retirement income, like Social Security.

Plan for a stable financial future with Gainbridge

Pensions provide a guaranteed source of retirement income, but they’re often just one part of a smart savings strategy. When you pair your pension with other investments, like annuities, you set yourself up for greater stability and financial wellness.

We offer two types of accounts — Traditional Save and Retirement Save — designed to support predictable income planning and complement the retirement resources you already have. Explore Gainbridge to learn how modern fixed annuities are built and how their guaranteed rates work. 

‍

This article is intended for informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide, and should not be interpreted as, individualized investment, legal, or tax advice. The Gainbridge® digital platform provides informational and educational resources intended only for self-directed purposes. 

‍